The judge determines the admissibility of evidence at a criminal trial, much as judge raulston did at the scopes trial. Scopes subsequently claimed, both immediately after the trial and in his autobiography, that he never had taught evolution, but that the drugstore conspirators were too busy drumming up publicity to let that deter them from bringing the trial to dayton. The jury itself being drawn from the largely biblebelieving population of the dayton, tennessee area. Raulston, the presiding judge in the scopes trial, had. A hollywood history of the 1925 scopes monkey trial. Watch monkey trial american experience official site pbs. Prosecution and defense teams choose members of the jury. John thomas scopes, which took place in daytons rhea county courthouse 1021 july 1925. As the eighteenth circuit court judge, raulston eagerly anticipated presiding over what he knew would be the most important case in his legal career. However, judge raulston barred further examination of bryan and ordered his prior testimony expunged from the record, stating that it was unrelated to the issue of whether scopes taught that man.
Kansas city july 10, 2000 seventyfive years ago to this very day, in the rhea county court house in dayton, tennessee, judge john raulston announced i am calling the case of the state vs. Prior to the scopes trial, a large part of judge raulstons criminal trial work involved trials for bootlegging whiskey. Scopes, charged with violating state law by teaching charles darwins theory of evolution. The scopes trial or monkey trial, as it was called dominated headlines. When you begin this book it would help if you have a basic understanding of the history and personages of the. Judge john raulston ruled out any test of the laws constitutionality or argument on the validity of. Scopes trial still significant, misunderstood us news. Timesmachine is an exclusive benefit for home delivery and digital subscribers. Preface how to use this book narrative overview events leading up to the scopes trial two sides prepare for trial the scopes trial begins fireworks in the courtroom bryan and malone cross swords an historic duel, a verdict reached the battle continues legacy of the scopes monkey trial biographies william jennings bryan. It was supposedly going to settle the question once and for all.
Scopes was an attack by citizens of dayton, tennessee, on a tennessee statute that banned the teaching of evolution in pub. In an impeachment trial, that duty falls on the senators, two of whom come from tennessee. John thomas scopes and commonly referred to as the scopes monkey trial, was an american legal case in 1925 in which a substitute high school teacher, john scopes, was accused of violating tennessees butler act, which made it unlawful to teach human evolution in any statefunded school. The scopes trial the worlds most famous court trial introductionby far the most celebrated court case in rhea county and perhaps in all of tennessee history was the case of the state of tennessee vs. In the excerpt below, mencken reflects on the trial s outcome and its overall importance for the united states. The scopes trial highlights the battle over evolution overview. It is debatable whether or not raulston allowed his personal support for the prosecution to affect his decisions during the course of the trial. Although his rulings more often favored the prosecution and his deference to bryan was especially obvious, raulston was credited with acting according to. Scopes trial, also called the monkey trial, highly publicized trial that took place july 1021, 1925, during which a dayton, tennessee, highschool teacher, john t. Raulston accelerated the convening of the grand jury and.
July 15, 1925 judge raulston overrules the defenses motion to have the. Inside the rhea county courthouse, the defense suffered early setbacks when judge john raulston ruled against their attempt to prove the law unconstitutional. Notably, raulston was an ordained methodist minister. Trial one of the most famous public permutations surrounding the issues of darwinism, religion in the classroom, and the separation of church and state was the 1925 scopes trial, also known as the monkey trial, held in dayton, tennessee. It was also intended as an intellectual battle royal between clarence darrow and william jennings bryan, two of the greatest minds of the early 20th century. On 10 july, 1925, the presiding judge john raulston began the trial by reading the first 27 verses of the biblical book of genesis which treat very unmistakeably with divine creation as the cause of existence. The scopes monkey trial80 years later answers in genesis. The 1925 scopes monkey trial has come to define the evolution vs. John tate raulston september 22, 1868july 11, 1956 was an american state judge in rhea county, tennessee, best known for presiding over the 1925 scopes trial, a famous creationismevolution debate. Remembering the scopes trial on may 25, 1925, john t. John tate raulston 18681956 wikitree free family tree. The basis for the scopes trial was a presumed violation of the butler act by teacher john scopes.
When schoolteacher john scopes was arrested for violating the butler act. For the most part, the trial has continue reading the scopes trial. The scopes trial took place on a hot july in 1925 in the little town of dayton nestled in the cumberland mountains of tennessee. The transcripts also include comments from the court i. John thomas scopes and commonly referred to as the scopes monkey trial, was an american legal case in july 1925 in which a high school teacher, john t. Scopesthe defendant in the famous monkey trialwas indicted for teaching the theory. Clarence darrow, arthur garfield hays, and dudley field malone.
Presiding judge at scopes monkey trial in 1925 was legislator in tennessee. Courthouse on july 10, 1925 for the first day of trial. I mean, literally to hear anything on the radio was fantastic, but to hear the scopes monkey trial. Scopes, which has come to be known famously as the scopes monkey trial, involved more than the conviction of just one man. He took a seat in the front row between his father and george rappalyea. The main speeches and arguments of the trial are readily available from the various books that have been written about the scopes trial, so what becomes fascinating in you be the judge are the stories behind the scenes of the trial. The scopes trial, formally known as the state of tennessee v. Raulston, the judge in the scopes trial, was a popular local attorney of no special competence.
The scopes trialformally known as the state of tennessee v. Scopes and evolution lost the monkey trial, but modernity. Scopes was being put on trial in a court of law, the merits of american fundamentalism were being put on trial in the court of public opinion. Scopes was found guilty of violating the butler act which had made it unlawful in tennessee to teach evolution in statefunded schools the act was not repealed until 1967. The trial is formally known as the state of tennessee v.
John thomas scopes, but is commonly referred to as the scopes monkey trial. The butler act declared that it was unlawful for a teacher in the public schools of tennessee to teach any theory that denies the story of the divine creation of man as taught in the bible, and to teach instead that man has descended from a. The transcript of the scopes trial is available on microfilm in most university law libraries, but for convenience in study, i chose to use a reprint of the original transcript published in its entirety at the time of the trial in the book, the worlds most famous court. The summer of the scopes trial, set in summer 1925.
John thomas scopes and commonly referred to as the scopes monkey trial. Raulston feared the floor might collapse and moved the trial outdoors, where about 5,000 people listened to the heated exchanges between bryan and darrow. Even though most scientists in the 1920s were sure that biology could not be taught without reference to evolution, christian fundamentalists saw evolutionary theory as a rejection of religious belief. Scopes, was accused of violating tennessees butler act, which had made it unlawful to teach human evolution in any. Raulston standing at far right on the steps of a building during the scopes monkey trial in which school teacher john scopes was prosecuted for teaching the theory of evolution in violation of tennessees butler act, dayton, tennessee, july 1925. When judge john raulston refused to admit expert testimony on the validity of. The scopes monkey trial is the bestknown example of the conflict over the teaching of evolution in the united states. The scopes trial and americas continuing debate over science and religion by edward j.
And with those simple words, the trial of the century was under way. The scopes trial highlights the battle over evolution. Remembering the scopes monkey trial eighty years ago, in july 1925, the mixture of religion, science and the public schools caught fire. Raulston, the presiding judge in the scopes trial, had proposed moving the trial under a tent that would have seated 20,000 people. Excerpt from how tennessees infamous scopes monkey trial can inform trumps impeachment trial the judge determines the admissibility of evidence at a criminal trial, much as judge raulston did at the scopes trial. The trial began on friday, july 10, 1925, with judge raulston calling on the. Scopes monkey trial legal definition of scopes monkey trial. Also in attendance were announcers ready to send to listeners the first live radio broadcast from a trial. Scopes, was charged with violating state law by teaching charles darwins theory of evolution.
On this day in 1925 in dayton, tennessee, the socalled monkey trial begins with john thomas scopes, a young high school science teacher, accused of teaching evolution in violation of a tennessee state law. The scopes monkey trial, as history would come to know it, also included a. Scopes trial, july 1021, 1925, dayton, tennessee, u. Bryans testimony climax of scopes trial upi archives. Although his rulings more often favored the prosecution and his deference to bryan was especially obvious, raulston was credited with acting according to his lights as well as his prejudices. I enjoyed reading this story about the scopes monkey trial of 1925 and how scopes. This is a readable, witty, informative look at the famous scopes monkey trial of 1925. The scopes monkey trial official name is state of tennessee v john thomas scopes began on july 10, 1925, in dayton, tennessee. John thomas scopes and commonly referred to as the scopes monkey trial, was an american legal case in july 1925 in which a substitute high school teacher, john t. John thomas scopes and informally known as the scopes monkey trialwas a landmark american legal case in 1925 in which high school science teacher, john scopes, was accused of violating tennessees butler act which made it. John tate raulston september 22, 1868 july 11, 1956 was an american state judge in rhea county, tennessee, who received national publicity for presiding over the 1925 scopes trial, a famous creationismevolution debate. On the first day of his trial, scopes appeared in court wearing a blue shirt and a handpainted bow tie. Scopes and evolution lost the monkey trial, but modernity won. In a time when modern court trials can drag on for months or even years, it is amazing to consider that the scopes trial lasted only 12 days july 1021including the selection of the jury.
The scopes trial, from the start, has been carried on in a manner exactly fitted to the anti evolution law and the simian imbecility under it. Monkeying with the scopes monkey trial answers in genesis. This book, now in its third edition, contains an accurate version of the official. The trial wasnt over, but judge john raulston had banned the testimony of the troupe of. Speech on the occasion of the 75th anniversary of the. The scopes festival celebrates the 1925 scopes evolution trial in dayton, tn, a clash of ideologies including human origins, science and religion, academic freedom, student rights, parental rights, control of public education, and majorityminority rights festival events include a reenactment of the trial, music, crafts, a classic car cruisein and more at the historic rhea county courthouse. Scopes trial project gutenberg selfpublishing ebooks. Scopes trial, also called the monkey trial, highly publicized trial that took place july 1021, 1925, during which a.
280 1430 328 108 1408 807 1556 1467 1375 363 76 1469 506 944 141 541 1215 46 539 460 744 771 1275 236 1025 782 1181 961 310 1587 547 1177 1217 741 240 1494 1198 179 1272 1120 651 1293